Scott Robertson’s departure as head coach of the All Blacks sparked intense debate across the rugby world, largely because of how quickly it happened and how it was ultimately framed.
What Happened?
Robertson’s tenure ended following an internal review by New Zealand Rugby early in the 2026 season cycle. Officially, the language used pointed to a mutual parting of ways, but in practice it was widely understood that the decision was driven by the governing body rather than by Robertson stepping away voluntarily.
This has led many fans to describe the exit as a firing in all but name, rather than a true resignation.
Why Was the Decision Made?
Several factors contributed to the call:
-
Inconsistent results at test level, despite a reasonable overall win rate
-
A handful of historic losses that raised alarm bells within NZ Rugby
-
Concerns that the team was not progressing quickly enough toward a clear, dominant identity
-
Pressure to reset early in the cycle with the 2027 Rugby World Cup in mind
In short, the performances were seen as acceptable by global standards — but not acceptable by All Blacks standards.
Fired vs Resigned: How It’s Viewed
-
Official stance: A review-led decision with agreement from both parties
-
Public perception: Robertson was effectively dismissed after failing to meet expectations
-
Reality: Likely a negotiated exit, allowing both sides to save face
Robertson himself acknowledged deep disappointment but stopped short of framing his departure as unfair, instead taking responsibility for results and expressing pride in the squad he helped build.
Reaction from Fans and Media
The response was sharply divided:
-
Some felt Robertson wasn’t given enough time, especially during a transition period
-
Others argued that All Blacks coaching is uniquely ruthless, and results matter immediately
-
Many pointed out the contrast between his long-term success at Super Rugby level and the short leash at international level
What This Means for His Legacy
Robertson’s exit doesn’t erase his reputation as an elite coach, but it does reinforce a familiar theme in New Zealand rugby: club dominance does not guarantee international success.
His All Blacks chapter will likely be remembered as:
-
A high-expectation appointment
-
A short and turbulent tenure
-
A reminder of how unforgiving the national coaching role can be
I will be your admin now.